Sunday, 16 October 2016

Grading vs. Learning

Grading provides a method of ranking students against each other, and sometimes against a norm.  They are used by various institutions (both educational and biusiness) to judge the characteristics of the student.  At this point, it's so ingrained societally that any alternative would be viewed with suspicion and distrust.  Unfortunately, the world of business behaves in a similar manner: it's focused on deadlines and results.  So, getting away from this paradigm will be difficult, to say the least.

I think it's absolutely clear that a lot of grading revolves around how well students take tests, and how well students are able to memorise the material that will be on the test. Of course, this only teaches the students to memorise the material long enough to take the test, and does not in any way encourage them to learn the material for life nor for any reason other than the test.

As it happens, I've already started my own process of de-emphasising test results.  This has happened due to my experiences with tutoring various struggling students.  Virtually every student wants to see me more often when a test is near, and they are always extremely stressed about the coming examination.  In recent years, I've added to my standard tutoring shtick the notion that the test is not the most important thing.  I make sure to note how well the student has done in demonstrating to me that they know the material and I insist that knowing the material is vastly more important than writing a good test.  I also stress that everyone won't write a good test every time, and a few dumb errors are to be expected, etc.  One of my main goals with this is simply to reduce their level of stress, because I firmly believe their test performance will be directly related to how comfortable and rested the student is.

Playing devil's advocate, though, I have to reiterate that the business world still works similarly, and wonder whether the student will be ready for that environment without the grade stress they feel now.  (Personally, I don't think it'll be a huge deal, but I also don't think it'll be completely negligible.)  That said, it makes me wonder how we can change the work environment, too.  After all, there are clearly ways to get better results, and for longer terms, by reducing continual high levels of stress.  It would be interesting to look into that.

No comments:

Post a Comment