Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Max van Manen: Tact

Here are some quotes that I found interesting:
  • Beginning: "In real situations the teachers must constantly and instantly act in a manner that hopefully demonstrates a thoughtful considerateness."
  • Middle: One teacher noted, regarding attempting active reflection in class: "Doing this quickly become highly frustrating. I feel that I become artificial and, in fact, the reflectiveness with which I approach the students, the class discussion, the presentation, or the class work that I do becomes an obstacle for a smooth lesson."
  • End: "If we were to ask the teacher to give an account of every one of her actions then she would most likely be stymied."

I will discuss these together, because I think they describe some general truths.  First, it's really important to be genuine, to be natural.  Show your real self, your real enthusiasm, and your real caring to the class.   Even if you come off as odd to them at first (as they may find the honesty and real emotion to be surprising), your genuine nature will quickly be recognised and appreciated by most, and this will help to foster a true respect.  When you betray a "falseness" (maybe nervousness, maybe unnatural pauses, or unusual responses, etc.), the students will immediately pick up on that, and it will be very difficult to foster the desired respect between you and the students.  As examples, the students can interpret this as dishonesty, or patronising behviour.  This is where forced reflection can be a real hindrance, as the teacher quoted above found.  It can derail the presentation of your natural self.

So, if forced reflection can be detrimental, what do we do?  I think it's important to understand that developing comfort and ease within a classroom will take time.  It's a daunting task to lead a classroom, to face a group of people in your charge, especially since you know they are relying on you -- perhaps without their actually realising it -- for something that is critically important to their human development.  I suspect reflection within the organised chaos of a classroom environment will be rare at best, and we must accept that, at least to an extent.  However, reflection will still be posssible, especially in the quieter moments (and even within the classroom at times), and we'll be able to use the results to improve our classroom presentation and management. 

Basically, it's going to take practice, a lot of practice, so don't expect to be perfect right away, and don't let early failures overwhelm you.  As you want your students to persevere through errors and difficult times, so must the teacher.

Sunday, 18 September 2016

Reflective Teaching: Openmindedness, Responsibility, and Wholeheartedness

According to Dewey, there are three main characteristics of a reflective teacher: openmindedness, responsibility, and whole-heartedness.  I feel the latter two items -- responsibility and wholeheartedness -- are clear and quite well understood.  They are often felt deeply by a person without much self-analysis needed.  Generally, people are taught from an early age to embrace these two characteristics.  On the other hand, I think openmindedness is much less often felt naturally this way, and thus can often be misunderstood, which may lead to misapplication.  I suspect it's not a characteristic that is instilled in youth in the same way as the other two characteristics.  It may, in fact, more often be the opposite.

Openmindedness can easily fall victim to some very natural pitfalls.  For example, it's very easy to be swayed by the latest fad, or even just by the last person we talked to.  Pressure to stay current could sometimes lead to change just for change's sake.  And it's even more complicated than that since sometimes the change or method will be valuable in some instances but not in others.  Making a change based on poor reasoning, or impulse or whim, is not being openminded.  For another example, it's difficult to open ourselves to review the things we believe, especially as some of these beliefs may be wound deeply within our cores.  For most, it won't be a natural characteristic, and will surely require effort to develop.

Openmindedness relies on the reasonable evaluation of argument, information and evidence.  It relies on one's critical thinking skills.  It is, in fact, a skill that must be developed.  It will take practice and mental effort to be able to learn to be openminded.  (I'm sure the ease with which it is learned varies substantially by person, but I suspect a quite small percentage of people will come by it naturally given the lack of attention it receives during our youths.)  Perhaps it's counter-intuitive, but I think developing real open-mindedness will require us to be patient and work to leave our emotional biases behind when we evaluate options and new ideas.

Friday, 16 September 2016

Frank McCourt

While Frank McCourt discusses his journey, he notes that he "discovered himself" through his teaching experiences.  This idea impacted me greatly, as it reminded me of my own experience.

While pursuing my Computer Science degree, I was fortunate (although the professor returning from Nepal who broke his leg might disagree) to have the opportunity to teach a first year Maths class despite having no experience, and only a B.Sc. in Math as credentials.  The first day while we waited outside the room for the custodian to unlock the door, no one recognised me as the instructor, and I felt a complete impostor.  I was almost overwhelmed by fear.  I wondered what I was doing there, as I'm an introvert and I'd always viewed class presentations as the worst and most terrifying part of school.

Fortunately, I found that once the class began, I was just fine, and the nerves and fear fell away completely, quickly replaced by powerful purpose and a strong desire to help these students however I might.  Over the course of the semester, my confidence grew and perhaps more importantly, my understanding of myself and my potential paths through life were completely rewritten.  It felt as though my eyes had opened to a new world and I had really seen myself within it for the first time.

Although I taught a couple more courses during that summer semester, my path veered into the business of software development, but that path now always included aspects of teaching.  

I found out in that first class that a desire to impact and educate people is just something that's a part of the very core of me.

Saturday, 10 September 2016

Six controversial statements about (mathematics) education

When we're young, our curiosity is boundless, and our self-consciousness is nearly non-existant.  We question and explore everything.  We wonder.  But, as time passes, we grow fearful, wary, pragmatic, and our curiosity diminishes.

There are many reasons for this, I expect.  It is certain that a part of it is developmental.  Many parents notice their child "playing strange" with unknown people at a certain age.  And with my children, there was a time when they didn't fear the dark at all, and then, quite suddenly it seemed, they did.  As the brain develops, young children develop self-awareness, and this clearly influences their perceptions of the world.

But, I think there's a larger issue at play.

With these statements, the common thread that stands out for men -- and I guess it shouldn't be a surprise given the course we're in -- is a lack of inquiry.  The students who identify with these statements have little interest in looking beyond the surface.  Their inborn natural curiosity has been stifled, and replaced with a kind of pragmatism.  They want no ambiguity, no extraneous information, just a method to quickly reach the current goal.

I'm worried that this is largely learned, driven partly by our societal environment, which focuses on results, endpoints and achievements, and much less on the journeys involved.  But also, it's a fight against time itself.  This battle with schedules and ever-marching minutes serves to train us into looking for the quickest and simplest route, and naturally forces us to narrow our focus.  

As teachers, I hope we can help the students uncover some of that stifled curiosity.  After all, with curiosity, the journey will be more interesting, and our students may be better able to handle those inevitable bumps in the road.