Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Max van Manen: Tact

Here are some quotes that I found interesting:
  • Beginning: "In real situations the teachers must constantly and instantly act in a manner that hopefully demonstrates a thoughtful considerateness."
  • Middle: One teacher noted, regarding attempting active reflection in class: "Doing this quickly become highly frustrating. I feel that I become artificial and, in fact, the reflectiveness with which I approach the students, the class discussion, the presentation, or the class work that I do becomes an obstacle for a smooth lesson."
  • End: "If we were to ask the teacher to give an account of every one of her actions then she would most likely be stymied."

I will discuss these together, because I think they describe some general truths.  First, it's really important to be genuine, to be natural.  Show your real self, your real enthusiasm, and your real caring to the class.   Even if you come off as odd to them at first (as they may find the honesty and real emotion to be surprising), your genuine nature will quickly be recognised and appreciated by most, and this will help to foster a true respect.  When you betray a "falseness" (maybe nervousness, maybe unnatural pauses, or unusual responses, etc.), the students will immediately pick up on that, and it will be very difficult to foster the desired respect between you and the students.  As examples, the students can interpret this as dishonesty, or patronising behviour.  This is where forced reflection can be a real hindrance, as the teacher quoted above found.  It can derail the presentation of your natural self.

So, if forced reflection can be detrimental, what do we do?  I think it's important to understand that developing comfort and ease within a classroom will take time.  It's a daunting task to lead a classroom, to face a group of people in your charge, especially since you know they are relying on you -- perhaps without their actually realising it -- for something that is critically important to their human development.  I suspect reflection within the organised chaos of a classroom environment will be rare at best, and we must accept that, at least to an extent.  However, reflection will still be posssible, especially in the quieter moments (and even within the classroom at times), and we'll be able to use the results to improve our classroom presentation and management. 

Basically, it's going to take practice, a lot of practice, so don't expect to be perfect right away, and don't let early failures overwhelm you.  As you want your students to persevere through errors and difficult times, so must the teacher.

1 comment:

  1. Good points, and I think the idea of reflecting in quiet moments is a good one. Usually there is a half hour or so after classes when there is a small space for contemplation and thinking over the events of the day (while putting away materials, writing notes for the following day's classes, etc.) Good advice to be prepared for some things that might go awry at any stage, and great advice to be genuine with your students.

    ReplyDelete